Reviews for Canon PowerShot G10 14.7 Megapixel Compact Camera - Black

3" LCD - 5x Optical Zoom - 4416 x 3312 Image - 640 x 480 Video - PictBridge - MPN: 2663B001

  • 1
  By member: Apollonarian - Jan 14, 2009

Dont buy this camera

Strengths: Are there any for a serious amateur photographer of 50 years experience? I go on image quality..

Weakness: image quality above 80 ISO is noisy. Above 200 it is useless.Above 400 it is a sick joke. Overcrowded tiny sensor. Useless focus LCD screen.Fussy multiple control buttons.

The movie mode has been reduced from the G9.The zoom also. Even at 80 ISO in controlled shots, white surfaces show unacceptable noise.The LCD is subject to damage and the camera does not fit in a pocket..then why call it a compact ? The Panasonice LX 3 is superior with less Megapixils, and pictures taken with an Olympus 4Mpixil are comparable. For me, this is a waste of money and an over cluttered toy with almost nothing to recommend it. this may be a good (not excellent) studio camera, but who wants it for that? I have plenty of good studio cameras..this promises plenty, delivers nothing and Canon..you have failed miserably with this excuse for a camera.Mine is back sealed in its box..next to a trade in place, and Ill be very careful of a Canon purchase next time..i challenge Canon to take this back and give me a model that delivers what is promises.

62% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

Top
Reply by member: sshus924
Feb 7, 2009

I have owned this camera for about 3 months and it is an excellent all around camera. Noise above ISO 80??? What are you kidding me! Picture quality up through ISO 400 is excellent. Read all of the pro reviews and they agree. The build quality is top notch and the picture quality and features are excellent. The video is more than acceptable for a non HD digita non-l video camera.... if you want superb video buy an HD video camera!

  • 2
  By member: ltj2003 - Nov 15, 2008

Terrible Disappointment

Strengths: Wide Angle lens, Outstanding high quality 3 inch display, good battery life, convenient, easy to use controls

Weakness: Only decent quality photos, no better than Canon models costing half as much money. Really bad noise levels at ISO 400 and higher. New DiGiC 4 is less reliable in setting a good exposure

I cannot be more disappointed in this camera. I was really thinking that I would get something superior for this much more money. This is my 4th Canon camera, and the first to disappoint me. Image quality is no better than my SX100 IS or S3 IS. All of the extra megapixels seem to make sharpness actually WORSE. In fact, exposures are often worse, as the new DiGiC 4 in this camera appears to be far less reliable than DiGiC 3 in my other Canons in automatically setting a good exposure. I'm having to manually override settings often with this camera in order to get good pics. This is totally unlike my other Canons, and I can only attribute it to the new DiGiC 4 system. It must have bugs in the firmware.

The 28mm 35mm equivalent wide angle zoom lens is a great feature, as is the outstanding high quality 3 inch screen. Battery life is good, and ergonomics excellent. Canon did somethings very good on this camera.

But I wanted a camera that delivers superior images, and this one does not do that. Noise level is absolutely terrible at higher ISO settings. Even hurts ISO 400 image quality, and ISO 1600 is a total joke, it is so extremely noisy.

My Canon Powershots A70, S3 IS, and SX100 IS have all been good, easy to use cameras. But I expected more from this camera due to its significantly higher price, and it clearly does not deliver on that hope. It is definitely overpriced for what you get.

This is one Canon to avoid. I wish that I had purchased the Powershot SX10 IS instead, as it has a larger sized sensor. But I really wanted something more compact, so that is why I unfortunately bought this model. This camera crams way too many megapixels into too small of a sensor, the the result is a camera that does not deliver on image quality.

The Powershot SX10 IS really is not that much bigger or heavier. And here it sells for over $100 less. I sadly bought the wrong new Canon. This camera is one of Canon's rare misses.

76% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

Top
Reply by member: ltj2003
Dec 11, 2008

Just want to update my review, as I have discovered additional technical problems with this camera, as I have been using it.

First, this new wide angle lens has been giving me some very bad color fringing in high contrast situations. Normally one would attribute this to a problem related to Chromatic aberration. However, this color fringing is actually colored orange, which is rather unusual. It is unfortunately also a very noticeable defect in the image when it does show up.

Could it maybe instead be caused by a problem with lens flare? it is only in smaller patches, which is also different from what you normally see in Chromatic aberration. But it is right on high contrast edges, which is where one would expect that to show up.

In any event, it is showing up in a number of images, especially when something white is contrasted against a dark background. And I've never, ever experience anything like this with any of my past 3 Canon PowerShots. And sadly, the new DIGIC4 firmware is not correcting this at all, like how some cameras can reduce Chromatic aberration.

As if this is not bad enough, the lens is also having an exceptional problem with ghosting when shooting into lights. I had some flash shots that were taken with some small Christmas lights in the background, and they caused ghost circles all over the image, totally ruining it.

Perhaps all of this is being caused by problems with this new lens that is in the G10 If so, the lens clearly has some serious flare and ghost issues in it.

Now to be fair, these shots were in tricky lighting circumstances. But one cannot always get ideal lighting for a shot. And again, I've never experienced anything like this before in the last 6 years that I have been using Canon digital cameras. And this is only a 5x zoom lens too. My S3 IS has a 12x zoom, and my SX 100 IS has a 10x zoom. But this zoom does start at a much wider angle, and these problems have been showing up when using the wider angle setting in the zoom.

I am so disillusioned with this camera at this point, that I think that I may sell it at a loss. The PowerShot that I would rather have at this point is the new PowerShot SD880 IS It also has a wide angle zoom that starts at the equivalent of 28mm on a 35mm camera. And it also shares the same great 3 " LCD screen. It also is much more compact, and can fit into a smaller pocket easily. And most of all, it costs far less money. Currently available for less than $250 I mainly just wanted the wider angle zoom feature, which is nice to have. And the SD880 IS also offers this, but for nearly $200 less in price than the G10.

Perhaps I just got a lemon. Who knows? I will go ahead and call Canon support, and see what they say about all of this. Maybe I can talk them into exchanging the camera.

  • 4
  By member: philldo - Nov 7, 2008

Sweet Camera

Strengths: Great Image Quality at lower ISO, Large LCD, Great unterface

Weakness: Higher ISO shots are a little noisy

So far, this is a great camera. The image quality is suburb at lower ISo.

The body feels really solid.

Works great with my 580 ex II flash. It does feel a little weird / top heavy when using a flash in the hot shoe.

72% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

Top
  • 4
  By member: tony_the_tiger - Nov 5, 2008

Canon Powershot G10 Black Digital Camera

Strengths: Excellent picture quality, best camera coming close to DSLR

Weakness: Weak zoom and noise

This is one of Canon's best camera's out. Definitely high megapixel and features 14.7-megapixel resolution for the highest image quality and editing flexibility,
5x optical zoom with Optical Image Stabilizer, 28mm wide-angle lens, DIGIC 4 Image Processor which improves Face Detection, full range of shooting and recording modes, including RAW, 3.0-inch PureColor LCD II with even greater true-to-life color reproduction. The problem is that it makes some sacrifices with a weaker 5X zoom than I am use to and digital noise at higher settings. I had a Canon S3 IS before and that zoom was much higher. However, the G10 does have a wide angle lens and supports an external flash, which are great in my opinion. I would say this is a great camera as long as you don't have expectations that this would replace a DSLR camera, but it comes very close.

53% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

Top
  • 5
  By member: FedericoGonzalez - Oct 28, 2008

GOOD OR BAD!

Strengths: Good picture quality.

Weakness: Lots of digital noise at high magnifications (enlargements)

GOOD OR BAD?
(FEDERICO GONZALEZ - 10/9/08)
No question about it! This camera is a great camera, but I guess the people at Canon could have done a much better job. Upgrading from an already great camera like the G9 had to be a very difficult task, but leaving great features out is a poor decision on their part. 5X zoom instead of 6X (addition of wider angle 28mm is great, but don't sacrifice telephoto 210mm). Movie resolution also sacrificied from 1024 X 768 back to 640 X 480. I guess they are not ready, or don't want to be ready for a high res. movie/still camera combo. Cosmetics don't look as good as the previous G9 (kind of funny: it took a while to get used to the design of the previous model (G9) and now they redesign it for worse). The new battery is great at twice the amps, but what about the people that invested lots of $'s on the previous NB-2LH batteries...not good for the consumer. The only reason why I considered the purchase of this camera was the ability to use a remote control (wired that is!), since I do a lot of long exposure work. The redesign of the lens to become a primarly wide angle lens is OK, but the people that got hooked on the telephoto capability of the camera, will be very dissapointed. Conclusion, the camera is a great addition to the Canon's digital arsenal, but they could have done a much better job.

81% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

Top
  • 3.0
  reviewgist.com - Dec 15, 2009

Best Digital Camera with Price Under $600 For Video

Image is Average according to 8 Digital Camera experts. -- "mostly accurate coloring"-pcworld.com -- "proper color temperature"-steves-digicams.com -- "With the pre-programmed AE modes even the beginning digi-photographer will be able to extend his picture taking abilities. with on-screen prompting to help everybody make better panoramics. balance, AE-Bracketing and flash exposure compensation...

Read Full Review

Top
  • 3.8
  productwiki.com - Jul 25, 2009

Canon VIXIA HF G10

The Canon VIXIA HF G10 is a camcorder built for ease of use and high quality recording. While the CMOS sensor is a basic 2 megapixel sensitivity that creates 1920 x 1080 resolution video, the lens is of a high quality that enables up to 10x optical zoom. A manual focus ring is also included for cases where auto-focus isnt appropriate. Dual SDXC slots allow for memory to be swapped out without...

Read Full Review

Top
  • 4.7
  TopTenREVIEWS.com - Dec 22, 2008

Canon Powershot G10

Canon Powershot G10 receives an overall TopTenREVIEWS score of 3.78 out of 4.00. It is ranked the #3 standard digital camera of all time. The overall rating represents an intelligent balance of features, value as a function of price to features, and a summary of reviews from a variety of sources. The TopTen REVIEWS' formula gives a picture of important consumer features, market value, and a...

Read Full Review

Top
  • 5.0
  bestcovery.com - Dec 3, 2008

Best Canon Digital Compact Camera

Bestcovery experts have rated the Canon Powershot G10 Black Digital Camera as the #1 Best Canon Digital Compact Camera. This product has also been ranked as the Best Advanced Compact Digital Camera and Best Digital Compact Camera for Wildlife, Sports and Action Photography. Bestcovery's experts recommend the best products and services for a particular need based on extensive research and...

Read Full Review

Top
  • 4.5
  Imaging Resource - Nov 28, 2008

Canon PowerShot G10

The Canon G10 is an impressive photographic tool for the discriminating enthusiast. The switch to a wider-angle lens than the G9 makes the G10 more useful for more types of photography, yet the 140mm end still gets in reasonably close for tighter compositions. Optical quality is good, with only moderate softening in the corners, and image quality is also impressive, with good color control and...

Read Full Review

Top
  • 4.0
  DCResource - Nov 23, 2008

DCRP Review: Canon PowerShot G10

The Canon PowerShot G10 is a very capable fixed-lens camera that does just about everything right. It's fast, well built, customizable, and expandable. Unfortunately, it's biggest problems relate to image quality, specifically to noise. Canon threw the highest resolution sensor they could find into the G10 (14.7 Megapixel), and they've had to apply a lot of noise reduction to keep noise in check....

Read Full Review

Top
  • 4.5
  cameralabs.com - Nov 11, 2008

Camera Labs – Canon PowerShot G10 review

Canon’s PowerShot G10 continues the G-series tradition of delivering high-end features and full manual control in a compact form factor. This is a well-built camera which will greatly appeal to enthusiasts or anyone looking for a pocketable backup to a DSLR. With the G10, Canon’s sensibly kept the full manual control, RAW recording and flash hotshoe of its predecessor, but made a number of...

Read Full Review

Top
  • 4.2
  testseek.com - Oct 30, 2008

Canon PowerShot G10

Testseek.com has collected 85 expert reviews for Canon PowerShot G10 and the average expert rating is 85 of 100. The average score reflects the expert community’s view on this product. Click below and use Testseek.com to see all ratings, product awards and conclusions.

Read Full Review

Top
  • 4.5
  photographyblog.com - Oct 27, 2008

Canon PowerShot G10 Review

The brand new PowerShot G10 is the most expensive and most feature-rich model in Canon’s extensive range of compact cameras. The G-series has long been the preserve of the keen enthusiast looking for a serious photographic tool that can still be easily slipped into a coat pocket. The new Canon G10 continues that tradition, adding even more advanced features into the mix, including a bigger 14.7...

Read Full Review

Top
  • 3.5
  cnet.com - Oct 24, 2008

Canon PowerShot G10

THE GOOD: Functional and fun shooting design; great enthusiast-oriented feature set; very nice photo quality THE BAD: Should be a little faster shot to shot. THE BOTTOM LINE: The Canon PowerShot G10 is a solid enthusiast digital camera for those who want something compact to complement a dSLR.

Read Full Review

Top